Climate Change, Biodiversity and the Political Process; Fall 2022
(an interdisciplinary course between International Relations, Biology, and Sustainability
taught by Dr. Jean Krasno and Dr. Ana Carnaval)
Class meets on Thursdays from 4:30 to 7 PM in Marshak 506
Course numbers: IR B6998; BIO 31907 (4RT-47704); BIO B9700 (5CWF-24630);
and SUS 9100B
Hours/credits: 3 credits
Instructors:
Dr. Jean Krasno, Colin Powell School of Civic and Global Leadership, City College of New York
Office: NAC 4146, 4th floor
Office hours: Tuesdays and Thursdays: 11:00am – 1:00pm (by appointment)
Dr. Ana Carnaval, City College of CUNY, Department of Biology
Office: MR-814 Marshak Science Building
Office hours flexible, by appointment
E-mail: acarnaval@ccny.cuny.edu , carolinacarnaval@gmail.com
Webpage: www.carnavallab.org
Co/Prerequisites: None
Course Description: This course brings faculty, students and experts from the field of environmental studies and biodiversity science together with those in the field of international policy making. Policy making on environmental sustainability must be grounded in a greater understanding of the sciences and the analysis of data on climate change, biodiversity, habitat loss and other contributing factors to the challenges of extinction, food security and extreme weather changes. In reverse, the sciences would benefit from a greater understanding of policy making, international law, the role of the United Nations, NGOs and the private sector, as policies are put into place that impact biodiversity and environmental sustainability.
Course Objectives: The course will provide students with a solid understanding of 1) the natural and human-mediated drivers of climate change and biodiversity habitat loss, 2) how environmental change translate in societal challenges that must be addressed holistically, including (but not limited to) extreme weather, food security, environmentally-mediated diseases, and environmental justice, and 3) how the political process, the systems of domestic and international laws, the United Nations, governments, NGOs and the private sector drive environmental preservation and impact ecological services at local to global scales. The course emphasizes critical thinking skills and environmental data interpretation while addressing political, social, cultural and economic challenges.
Course learning objectives:
After completing this course, students should be able to: |
1. Explain in their own words how environmental shifts impact biodiversity, ecosystem services, and human societies, globally |
2. Find, comprehend and interpret peer-reviewed scientific data and methods describing environmental shifts at multiple spatial scales, and their societal impacts |
3. Interpret documented changes in climate phenomena, species conservation status, or ecosystem services as a function of existing policies and the political process in place at local, regional, national and/or international scales. |
4. Design and contrast alternative viable environmental policies to address a specific environmental goal |
5. Discuss how science and policy interact to impact the benefits of nature to people |
6. Present findings and solutions to problems identified through their own independent inter-disciplinary research on climate change, biodiversity and the political process |
Required Readings:
- Chasek, Pamela S; David L. Downie and Janet Welsh Brown, Global Environmental Politics, 7th edition, 2017, Boulder, CO: Westview Press. For purchase.
- Rosenbaum, Walter A., Environmental Politics and Policy, 11th edition, 2020, Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications (CQ Press). Electronic version will be emailed to students.
- Scientific articles and additional book chapters to be made available on Blackboard.
Additional (suggested) readings: Nico Schrijver, Chapter 3 in Development Without Destruction, “Management of the Global Commons;” (on Blackboard)
Course overview:
Classes are based on cross-disciplinary discussions of both the primary scientific literature and political science literature, and each session is co-led by Science, Sustainability, and International Relation students (co-presenters). In preparation for every class, every student will 1) read and analyze primary research articles and policy book chapters to extract main conclusions from the texts and figures, and summarize findings, 2) identify connections between the scientific observations and data and the political processes addressed by the readings, 3) write and reflect on up to four questions about the readings and their integration, in preparation for discussion. Science and Sustainability MS students will additionally summarize, in writing, the scientific article that they will present in class (every student presents an article once throughout the semester). At each class period, three or two students will each make a 10-minute presentation on a relevant assigned reading, and launch the discussion.
Please select the topic and class day you would like to present here:
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1k5VWXZTYK11NtcrcZhzewmw_NGG1rfm…
All students are required to speak at every class – either leading the discussion, presenting an article or book chapter, sharing a question, or making a comment. Points will be removed from a student’s final grade if they do not speak up in class.
Instead of an exam, students will work in multi-disciplinary groups of three or two students to write two papers throughout the course: one mid-term (5-6 pages) that contextualizes and summarizes an environmental problem, data demonstrating how this problem impact biodiversity, and the existing policies that impact the issue, and one final paper (10-12 pages) in which the original essay is revised and extended to include suggestions of policy changes and how to implement them, along with a policy regime. At the end of the course, each group will give a short (no more than 10 min) presentation on the main findings of their final research paper, and discuss it with the class. Students will select their own projects from the list below, and will be free to define the regional scope of their study.
Deforestation or loss of natural habitats
Climate change and ocean health (e.g. coral reefs, or fisheries, etc)
Climate change and extreme weather events
Climate change and wildfires
Climate change and air pollution
Climate change and environmental justice
Investing on renewable energy to address climate change (biomass, solar, wind, hydro) – promises and challenges
Climate change and impacts on animal/human interactions (pathogens, infectious diseases, global health)
Climate change and its impacts on the water cycle
Climate change and food security
Please indicate your interest in these topics, so that we can form your groups, here: https://forms.gle/R3FCNTHjknTxzafB6
On November 17 all students will participate in a simulation of the United Nations Security Council.
Field Trips: We are organizing two field trips during the course – one to Little Island Park (date and time TBD), and one to UN Headquarters. These trips are planned for Fridays, in the afternoon, starting at 4 PM. We understand some students who work may not be able to attend and will not be penalized for not attending.
Assessment tools and grading: Grades will be assigned based on the mid-term paper, the final research paper, and student class participation. The latter will reflect attendance, written weekly questions, presentations, participation in class discussion and participation in the simulation exercise. If you know that you will miss a class, contact the instructor as soon as possible with your justification.
The final grade will be calculated as follows: |
|
Class participation |
30% |
Mid-term paper |
30% |
Final research paper |
40% |
Grammar, spelling and composition: Students must use proper spelling, grammar (including punctuation) and composition. Unintelligible sentences and illegible answers will be given no credit. Paragraphs must be composed of organized, coherent thoughts and include a lead sentence for proper composition. The instructors are available during office hours or by appointment to answer questions regarding writing and composition.
Academic Integrity: Plagiarism will not be tolerated; it will be dealt with subject to CCNY/CUNY policies regarding academic integrity. The full CUNY policy can be found in the CCNY Graduate and Undergraduate Bulletin 2013-2015 (see Appendix B.3) and on the CUNY website. Cases where academic integrity is compromised will be prosecuted according to these rules.
Attendance Policy: Classes begin promptly, and you are required to be on time. Attendance is required.
Weekly Schedule:
Aug 25: Week one: Introduction: Biodiversity and the Environmental Debate: the Domestic and International Policy Process:
Readings: On Blackboard Content:
- Summary of the Paris Agreement on Climate Change
- Summary of the Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD)
- Summary of the links between biodiversity and environmental change
Please read these documents and be ready to discuss.
Additional (suggested) readings: Summary for Policymakers of the International Panel for Climate Change and of the International Panel for Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services.
Sept 1: Week two: A Historical Overview of Environmental Policy and Biodiversity – and a closer look into air pollution
Readings:
- Rosenbaum, Chapter 1: A history of US environmental policy under different presidents
- Summary of Impacts of Air Pollution
Please read these documents, the summaries sent along with them, and be ready to discuss.
Sept 8: Week three: Domestic environmental policy making – and a closer look into water pollution
Readings:
- Rosenbaum, Chapter 2: the process of making US environmental policy, agenda setting.
- Zerebecki et al. 2022. Biodiversity influences the effects of oil disturbance on coastal ecosystems. Ecology and Evolution 12: e8532. https://doi.org/10.1002/ece3.8532
Please read these documents, the summaries sent along with them, and be ready to discuss.
Sept 15: Week four: Regulating water and air, and monitoring biodiversity
Readings:
- Rosenbaum, Chapter 3: Making policy and governmental departments and agencies; WOTUS, defining “navigable” waters; air and water pollution and toxic hazardous substances)
- Cavender-Bares et al. 2022. Integrating remote sensing with ecology and evolution to advance biodiversity conservation. Nature Ecology & Evolution 6: 506–519.
Please read these documents, the summaries sent along with them, and be ready to discuss.
Sept 16. 4-5:30 PM. Friday, Field Trip to Little Island (to be confirmed)
Sept 22: Week five: Science and Risk Assessment and Environmental Justice
Readings:
- Rosenbaum, Chapters 4 and 5: “Common Policy Challenges,” How do agencies use science to determine risks of hazardous materials; When poisons impacts us; problems of environmental and social injustice, and the battle over regulatory economics.
- News piece “Climate Change Likely to Increase US Income Inequality,” uploaded as text to Blackboard
- Hsiang et al. 2017. Estimating economic damage from climate change in the United States. Science 356 (6345), 1362-1369
Please read these documents, the summaries sent along with them, and be ready to discuss.
September 29: No Class, Courses follow a Monday schedule
Oct 6: Week six: Habitat Loss, Extinction, and Conservation
Readings:
- Rosenbaum, Chapter 9 (Public lands)
- Hernandez, J. 2022. Fresh banana leaves: healing indigenous landscapes through indigenous science. Introduction (pg 1-16) and Chap 3: Birth of Western Conservation (pg 69-98)
Please read these documents, the summaries sent along with them, and be ready to discuss.
Oct 13: Week seven: Climate change, US politics, and food security.
GUEST SPEAKER: ALEX MCALVAY (New York Botanical Gardens)
Readings:
- Jeffrey Sachs, The Age of Sustainable Development, Chapter ten: “Food Security” (on Blackboard)
- Rosenbaum, Chapter 10: US politics and global climate change
- McAlvay et al. 2021. Ethnobiology Phase VI: Decolonizing Institutions, Projects, and Scholarship. Journal of Ethnobiology, 41(2): 170-191
- Steven R. McGreevy et al. 2022. Sustainable agrifood systems for a postgrowth world. Nature Sustainability https://doi.org/10.1038/s41893-022-00933-5
Please read these documents, the summaries sent along with them, and be ready to discuss.
Oct 20: Week eight: Midterm paper presentations (5 minutes per team, followed by discussion)
Midterm papers are due.
Policy Regime explanation.
Oct 27: Week nine: Public Health and Pathogens
Readings:
- Chasek et al: Chapters 1 and 2, The Emergence of Global Environmental Politics;” and “Actors in the Environmental Arena,”
- Jeffrey Sachs, The Age of Sustainable Development, Chapter nine: “Health for All” (on Blackboard)
- Dobson et al. 2020. Ecology and economics for pandemic prevention. Science 369 (6502): 379-381
- Gillespie et al. 2021. COVID-Clarity demands unification of health and environmental policy. Glob Change Biol. 2021;27:1319–1321.
Nov 3: Week ten: International Law, the Environment, and science engagement
Readings:
- Chasek et al: Chapter 3: The Development of Environmental Regimes (ozone, waste, chemicals and Climate Change)
- Barnosky et al. 2014. Translating science for decision makers to help navigate the Anthropocene. The Anthropocene Review Vol. 1(2) 160–170.
Nov 10: Week eleven: The Sustainable Development Goals: A Sustainable Environment
Readings:
- Chasek Chapter 4: Development of Environmental Regimes (biodiversity, endangered species, forests, etc)
- Strassburg, B.B.N., Beyer, H.L., Crouzeilles, R. et al. Strategic approaches to restoring ecosystems can triple conservation gains and halve costs. Nature Ecology and Evolution 3, 62–70 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41559-018-0743-8.
Nov 11:. 4-5:30: PM. Friday field trip. The United Nations, Tour of the United Nations in New York City; expert presentations on climate change issues.
Nov 17: Week twelve: UN Security Council simulation: Climate Change as a threat to international peace and security.
Nov 24: No class, Thanksgiving
Dec 1: Week thirteen: Student research presentations.
Dec 8: Week fourteen: Student research presentations. Final papers due.
Last Updated: 11/29/2022 17:08